EGA meeting Barcelona 2009: commoditisation risks sustainability of generic medicines market

Home/Conferences | Posted 01/09/2009 post-comment0 Post your comment

The commoditisation of generic medicines markets could be a real threat to the sustainability of the industry, Ms Francesca Bruce of Scrip News heard at the European Generic medicines Association's (EGA) annual conference recently held in Barcelona, Spain.

According to Mr Peter Burema, Managing Director of Anneville Healthcare Consultancy, they have been focusing on switching to generics, but should not give them away as the cheapest commodity. He pointed to the UK, where the manufacturer's selling price for simvastatin 28 x 20 mg tablets is GBP0.16 (Euros 0.18), which adds up to around GBP1.92 (Euros 2.23) per patient per year. Thus it costs less than a Starbuck's cappuccino, he argued. Overall, generics take up around 79% of the total UK pharma market, and INN unbranded generics account for just below 60% of the not patent-protected market.

A commodity business model is not sustainable, but it could be an uphill struggle to stop it taking hold everywhere. “UK prices could become a reality elsewhere,” he said. In The Netherlands, healthcare authorities have introduced new tendering systems that exclude unsuccessful bidders from the market, while discount contract tendering is hitting generic medicines prices in Germany.

Meanwhile, the quality of generic medicines is improving and the cost of registering a product is increasing. Good manufacturing practices are becoming more stringent, as are pharmacovigilance burdens, while firms have to meet demands specific to each market, for example on blister sizes.

The consequences for the industry are severe. Patent expires worth more than US$110 billion (Euros 78.98 billion) will take place between 2010 and 2012 (according to IMS Health) but could generate just US$2.3 billion (Euros 1.65 billion) in revenues for the generic medicines industry, warned Mr Burema. Profits are already falling despite increasing market share, and some firms may even face losses, he said.

“Companies will move in and out of the market based on pricing levels because nobody can, or wants, to sell at a loss,” he said. This means that both pharmacists and patients could change manufacturers on a regular basis. Disrupted supply would then compromise trust in generic medicines and cause healthcare professionals to switch to newer products that are more costly despite not necessarily having the same benefit.

Certain pack sizes and strengths that are not profitable enough could disappear, resulting in less choice for patients. Some molecules could even vanish from the market altogether. Mr Burema urged industry to actively lobby for a branded generics market, which would ultimately lead to more incremental innovation. He also argued a ‘sensible’ reference pricing system should accompany a doctor's free prescribing rights.

Source: Scrip

comment icon Comments (0)
Post your comment
Related content
Pekka Kurki receives Van der Does Award
GW 5017K Kurki
Home/Conferences Posted 20/06/2023
DIA Europe 2023 – a brief report
DIA logo V23D20LT
Home/Conferences Posted 20/04/2023
Most viewed articles
About GaBI
Home/About GaBI Posted 06/08/2009
EU guidelines for biosimilars
EMA logo 1 V13C15
Home/Guidelines Posted 08/10/2010